Herb Substitutes: From Basil to Thyme

herb substitutes

Do you know which herb substitutes to use in an emergency?

We’ve all been there when suddenly we realize that the herb we thought we had on the shelf isn’t there!

We are following a recipe, it’s calling for that particular herb!

What to do?

Don’t panic, there are solutions.

With food, there are always solutions.

So which herb substitutes can you use in the foods you are making while staying as close to the original flavor as possible? 


The main thing is not to worry, and with the help of this post, hopefully you can learn what are the best ways to find alternatives to your herb ingredients.

How can your herb garden come to the rescue in a time of need?

What are good herb substitutes?

Let’s take a look at some specific herbs.

Bestseller No. 1
iDOO Hydroponics Growing System 12Pods, Indoor Garden with LED Grow Light, Plants Germination Kit, Built-in Fan, Automatic Timer, Adjustable Height Up to 11.3″ for Home, Office
  • 20% Faster than Soil Planting: The integrated low noise pump of hydroponics growing system aerates the water to stimulate plant growth while the upper fan simulates the outside breeze at timed intervals. Grow your plants 20% faster than the traditional soil planting method.
  • 4.5L Water Tank and Fan: Hydroponics growing system built-in a fan which spreads pollen in florescence, disperses heat in germination. Indepandent 4.5L water tank can support plants to grow for 1-2 weeks in the growth period. A visual window can see how much water in tank.
Bestseller No. 2
AeroGarden Harvest with Gourmet Herb Seed Pod Kit – Hydroponic Indoor Garden, White
  • INCLUDES GOURMET HERB SEED KIT (6-POD) – Genovese Basil, Curly Parsley, Dill, Thyme, Thai Basil and Mint & a 3oz bottle of our patented, all natural Plant Nutrients (enough for a full season of growth).
  • ALWAYS HOMEGROWN: FRESH & SAFE – Up to 6 plants grow at a time, up to 12“ tall with this indoor garden. Grows in water – no soil, no mess, made simple.
Bestseller No. 3
Barnyard Designs Farmhouse Herb Garden Planter Indoor Planter Set with Tray or Outdoor Apartment Window Planter Box, Windowsill Planter Box, Indoor Herb Planter Garden Pots Herb Pots, White, Set/3
  • Indoor herb garden planter with tray – Add greenery to your space with this vintage metal windowsill planter. Herb planters for indoor plants with a farmhouse touch. Place the indoor herb planter on your kitchen counter or display the small herb planter as an apartment window planter.
  • Decorative window planter – Keep your fresh herb plants and spices like basil and rosemary close at hand! Or, fill the decorative indoor planter with small plants, flowers or mini succulents. The perfect herb garden planter, indoor or outdoor.
SaleBestseller No. 4
AeroGarden Sprout with Gourmet Herbs Seed Pod Kit – Hydroponic Indoor Garden, Black
  • BRAND NEW DESIGN – Experience better plant growth from your AeroGarden Sprout indoor garden with a sleek modern look, new silent pump, and simple soft-touch button to control lights and reset plant food reminders
  • PLANT TO PLATE – up to 3 plants can be grown at a time, up to 10″ tall. Plants grow in water, not soil – an advanced indoor garden made simple


SWAP FOR: Oregano or Thyme

herb substitutes

Oregano and thyme are two of the most widely used herbs, and originate from the Medeteranean region.

Related Recipe:  Za’atar (Herbal Spice Mix for Life)

Even though basil originated in India, it is widely used in countries around the Mediterranean.

Often we associate dishes with basil to also contain oregano and thyme.

Even though dried basil remains sweeter and more herbal than the other two, they can be exchanged quite adequately.

In fact they are often found together in Italian seasoning. 


SWAP FOR: Basil, Oregano or Marjoram

herb substitutes

Thyme is not particularly aromatic, but has a very well rounded flavor that when used correctly with complementary herbs allows for a robust taste.

Thyme is a member of the mint family, and a close relation to oregano, and therefore can be substituted for oregano easily.

Marjoram is slightly pungent and a bit spicy, and combine with a little parsley can be a great substitute for thyme.


SWAP FOR: Marjoram, Savory or Rosemary

herb substitutes

Savory is an herb that is described as being full in flavor and therefore a good substitute for sage.

Sage is described as sweet and somewhat bitter, with lemon and eucalyptus notes making it also a full flavored herb.

Related Recipe:  Cilantro Garlic Sauce (Creamy & Simple)

Marjoram is also a strong flavor as is rosemary, making them good substitutes as well. 


SWAP FOR: Thyme or Basil

herb substitutes

Oregano tastes a bit woodsy, and has an earthy flavor, making it a bit bolder than the taste of basil, but the sweetness is strong enough that you can taste the herbalism in a dish that can help mimic the herbal flavor of oregano.

Thyme can complement other herbs to give a well-rounded taste you can get from oregano.  


SWAP FOR: Cilantro or Chervil


Chevil is from the carrot family which is related to parsley, and therefore a good substitute for parsley.

Chervil has a bit of a stronger flavor but works well. Cilantro works as well, although with a more distinctive flavor.

Dill Weed

SWAP FOR: Tarragon

dill weed

Both these herbs have a bittersweet characteristic, with a mild taste of anise seed to them which allows for a seamless substitution. 


SWAP FOR: Parsley


Cilantro will have a bit of a stronger and more distinctive flavor than parsley, but the fresh taste of both can be easily interchangeable. 

Related Recipe:  Dukkah (Delicious Dipping Mix of The Ages)

Bay Leaf 

SWAP FOR: ¼ tsp Dried Thyme

bay leaf

Bay leaf is very pungent, bitter and sharp flavor when eaten whole.

Once dried, bay leaf can taste very much like dried thyme.

Instead of being overpowering, it gently flavors any dish when substituting dried thyme. 


SWAP FOR: Scallions or Leek


Chives are related to leaks, garlic, and onions.

With a very gentle onion flavor along with a hint of garlic, chives are distinctive, but definitely oniony.

Scallions or leeks with the understated taste of onion are a perfect match. 

I hope that was helpful and that you found the herb substitutes you were looking for.

Do you have any suggestions?

I’d love to hear about them in the comments below!

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *